Federici - the best keeper in the Championship?

[FinchOwl]

How Kelvin Davis was in the ccc team of the year instead of him is beyond me. Feders has single handedly won 3 points for us at times!

we'd of won the title last tuesday if not for Kelvin Davis' performance way back whenever it was we played Saints at home

He was also ridiculously good away at Leeds, Saints won 1-0 I think

Still think Feds is better mind

[Linden Jones' Tash]

some thoughts here on the team vs. last time

http://thetwounfortunates.com/reading-f ... rspective/

[Silver Fox]

How Kelvin Davis was in the ccc team of the year instead of him is beyond me. Feders has single handedly won 3 points for us at times!

we'd of won the title last tuesday if not for Kelvin Davis' performance way back whenever it was we played Saints at home

He was also ridiculously good away at Leeds, Saints won 1-0 I think

Still think Feds is better mind

Oh I agree, I just think bracks has somewhat oversimplified his argument for Fed

I don't know if it's been mentioned elsewhere but do the PFA members still vote ridiculously early? In which case Davis would of been a shoe-in, although I don't know where Hartey got his votes from

[pea]

Oh I agree, I just think bracks has somewhat oversimplified his argument for Fed

I don't know if it's been mentioned elsewhere but do the PFA members still vote ridiculously early? In which case Davis would of been a shoe-in, although I don't know where Hartey got his votes from

End of March

[TBM]

Grown his hair for the new season

[Geekins]

Sal Bibbo's love child

[Big Ern]

Sal Bibbo's love child

It always puzzles me why Bibbo seems to be a very good GK coach when he was such a shite GK during his professional career?

[Alexander Litvinenko]

Sal Bibbo's love child

It always puzzles me why Bibbo seems to be a very good GK coach when he was such a shite GK during his professional career?

Those who can't do .....

[NattMiles]

Grown his hair for the new season

Proper sexy

[TBM]

Bump

From todays game....

Reading goalkeeper Adam Federici made a string of quality saves.

I still think he is one of the best in the Championship.

[Mr.Swainey]

He is one of the best in the Championship, but at the moment he isn't even the best keeper at the club.

[kwik-silva]

I'm not sure. McCarthy definitely has the potential to go on and become a great keeper, but on the basis of last season I wouldn't say that he's there yet. The end of the PL season he was quality, but he didn't live up to that last year. I'd say they're about level.

[RG7Fan]

Both are way too slow at getting the ball back out after they pick it up. They always seem to wave the players forward and give the opposition time to re-form when we might have a couple of players free for a break.

[The Real Sandhurst Royal]

RG7Fan wrote: Both are way too slow at getting the ball back out after they pick it up. They always seem to wave the players forward and give the opposition time to re-form when we might have a couple of players free for a break.

Team orders

[RoyalBlue]

He is one of the best in the Championship, but at the moment he isn't even the best keeper at the club.

At the moment he is the best at the club. The fact that QPR may be about to spend £3M on McCarthy doesn't alter that. Equally the fact that there doesn't appear to be a number of clubs fighting for McCarthy's signature would suggest that he has dropped back from the peak of form that he displayed and that there are concerns about areas of his game, particularly his kicking/distribution.

[kwik-silva]

Both are way too slow at getting the ball back out after they pick it up. They always seem to wave the players forward and give the opposition time to re-form when we might have a couple of players free for a break.

I'm pretty sure that's deliberate due to the way Adkins wants to play, but I could be wrong!

[Simon's Church]

He's top 30 for sure

[Pepe the Horseman]

Not even one of the top 30 keepers at the club.

[Big Foot]

He weighs 30 stone, agreed

[sandman]

Dry your eyes m8s.