ZacNaloen I hope we are going to see a graph at the end of all this.
Yeah, really can't be bothered - especially as it's not exactly going to my hypotheses!
Will wait for 40 answers and then do an awesome page of graphs etc
Profiling
-
PistolPete
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 1349
- Joined: 01 Mar 2005 06:38
- Location: 1871
Yeah, really can't be bothered - especially as it's not exactly going to my hypotheses!
Will wait for 40 answers and then do an awesome page of graphs etc
-
Ian Royal
- Hob Nob Legend
- Posts: 35156
- Joined: 15 Apr 2004 13:43
- Location: Playing spot the pc*nt on HNA?
St. BrynjarExtended-Phenotype My guess would be that if you don't like a players character you will find it harder to praise them and ultimately you will pick up on more of their mistakes, possibly even fabricate problems with their game to fit your personal gripe with them.
Definitely true for me. I always give Pearce, HRK and Le Fondre harder times than they deserve.
It's a factor for sure. With some players I'm quite good at taking my prejudice into account and with others I'm not.
I think it comes down to that I'll defend a player I don't like providing I don't think there's a clear better option available. I used to defend Federici, because he's a good keeper, despite thinking he's a dick. But now we've got McCarthy who I think is better so I'm less tolerant of his weaknesses.
And of course, liking and rating a player doesn't necessarily mean you think they are good enough to be playing. Ledge for example, I like and rate. But he simply wasn't a PL quality player.
-
CavershamRoyal
- Member
- Posts: 461
- Joined: 26 May 2011 16:59
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
-
SPARTA
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 4742
- Joined: 23 Sep 2012 17:40
- Location: If you give us 90 minutes, we'll give you a lifetime
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - No
Did you like him as a character? Yes
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - Yes
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - No
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - Indifferent
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - Dislike
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - Dislike
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - Dislike
As a player, Jay Tabb - Indifferent
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - Like
As a player, Matt Mills - Indifferent
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - Dislike
Did you like him as a character? Yes
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - Yes
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - No
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - Indifferent
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - Dislike
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - Dislike
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - Dislike
As a player, Jay Tabb - Indifferent
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - Like
As a player, Matt Mills - Indifferent
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - Dislike
-
weybridgewanderer
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 2372
- Joined: 19 Nov 2005 23:08
- Location: is it time to go home?
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Other than that people have different opinions I am not sure what we are proving
Ask 40 people that sit near mea at the mad stad about me and you will probably get a similar spread of responses.
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Other than that people have different opinions I am not sure what we are proving
Ask 40 people that sit near mea at the mad stad about me and you will probably get a similar spread of responses.
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - NO
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
-
Man Friday
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 2856
- Joined: 20 Nov 2005 13:45
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE/INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE/INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
-
PistolPete
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 1349
- Joined: 01 Mar 2005 06:38
- Location: 1871
33 replies - 17 more and I'll spend ages making lots of fancy graphs which by the looks of things will prove nothing!
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - NO
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - INDIFFERENT
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Did you like him as a character? INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
-
TheBaldOne
- Member
- Posts: 139
- Joined: 07 Jan 2013 18:45
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - NO
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a player, Jay Tabb - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
-
Whore Jackie
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 2845
- Joined: 09 Feb 2006 13:48
- Location: Over 'ere
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Matt Mills - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - INDIFFERENT
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Matt Mills - DISLIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
-
6 Million Dollar Man
- Member
- Posts: 60
- Joined: 24 Mar 2013 21:29
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
Did you like him as a character? YES
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - INDIFFERENT
-
Extended-Phenotype
- Hob Nob Addict
- Posts: 5977
- Joined: 27 May 2011 10:43
- Location: Oxford Road
PistolPete 33 replies - 17 more and I'll spend ages making lots of fancy graphs which by the looks of things will prove nothing!
I'd say this has been an unexpected triumph regardless of the pending graphwork.
-
Zana Badawi
- Member
- Posts: 373
- Joined: 29 Oct 2013 19:18
Extended-Phenotype My guess would be that if you don't like a players character you will find it harder to praise them and ultimately you will pick up on more of their mistakes, possibly even fabricate problems with their game to fit your personal gripe with them.
Im not even sure how you can assess their character apart from what you see when they're playing. Its not like you meet them socially is it?
I would say whether you like a player or not depends on whether you rate them as a footballer.
So, taking that into account, Im gonna say indifferent to all the characters, Dislike Pog and Guthrie, Like the rest and No to Rodgers' sacking.
-
Extended-Phenotype
- Hob Nob Addict
- Posts: 5977
- Joined: 27 May 2011 10:43
- Location: Oxford Road
Zana BadawiExtended-Phenotype My guess would be that if you don't like a players character you will find it harder to praise them and ultimately you will pick up on more of their mistakes, possibly even fabricate problems with their game to fit your personal gripe with them.
Im not even sure how you can assess their character apart from what you see when they're playing. Its not like you meet them socially is it?
I would say whether you like a player or not depends on whether you rate them as a footballer.
That's why I think it's pretty stupid when folk say they hate/dislike one of our players. All they have to go on is negligible media garbage. Guthrie a good example; we don't and probably never will know what went on there but most Reading fans "detest" him.
Weird.
most?
i h8 him cos of his hair
i h8 him cos of his hair
-
The Goat was fed
- Member
- Posts: 407
- Joined: 10 May 2004 15:59
- Location: Looking a right tool on TV
Did you want Rodgers out when he was sacked - YES
Did you like him as a character? NO
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills -INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Did you like him as a character? NO
As a player, do you like or dislike Guthrie - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Guthrie - DISLIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Federici - LIKE
As a player, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - LIKE
As a character, do you like or dislike Pogrebnyak - INDIFFERENT
As a player, Jay Tabb - INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Tabb - LIKE
As a player, Matt Mills -INDIFFERENT
As a character, do you like or dislike Mills - DISLIKE
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 107 guests
It is currently 28 Jun 2025 21:45