sandman It's all about opinions, I'm not going to try and change your mind but I think Feds deserves a bit more respect than he's been getting.
Frustratingly, because I think McCarthy will be a far better keeper for us if given a season of games, I don't think Fed has really done enough to justify dropping him just yet, I just wouldn't have started with him in the first place.
For all the fact I'd prefer McCarthy, my grumbling about Feds isn't that I think he's shit, it's that I've got a prefered alternative. If we didn't have McCarthy I'd probably be backing Feds.