MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

222 posts

Result predictor

Poll runs till 02 Nov 2025 12:02
Reading win
20
67%
Draw, Reading win in ET
2
7%
Draw, Reading win on penalties
2
7%
Carlisle win
2
7%
Draw, Carlisle win in ET
3
10%
Draw, Carlisle win on penalties
1
3%
 
Total votes: 30
Sutekh
Hob Nob Legend
Posts: 23650
Joined: 12 Feb 2014 14:05
Location: Over the hills and far away

Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

by Sutekh » 30 Oct 2025 13:15

The winner of this game will net £47,750 in prize money

The loser gets £15,800.

Mid Sussex Royal
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 4230
Joined: 02 Nov 2008 17:56

Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

by Mid Sussex Royal » 30 Oct 2025 13:17

windermereROYAL
royals6719
Jackson Corner Reading have only once lost at home to a non league club. I was at that game possibly one of the most depressing miserable experiences l can remember as a Reading fan. Anyone else on this board remember it?



Bishops Stortford 1-2!!! in the mud. Remember it well -


Yes a horrible experience, we were losing for a long time when Steve Moran volleyed a superb equaliser only for a late goal keeping mistake let them in for a late winner.


Pretty sure Maurice Evans was manager so before Steve Moran's time? may be wrong though, memory not what it was.

I do remember we lost to a last minute goal though.

Clyde1998
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 3571
Joined: 04 Mar 2010 16:27

Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

by Clyde1998 » 30 Oct 2025 15:01

Royals and Racers
Clyde1998 Looks like slow ticket sales thus so (shock!): 1,562 home tickets sold based on the seat map (not counting disabled or hospitality).

Carlisle appear to have sold 536 out of their 559 allocation so far.

Any chance Clyde of an update- new manager ticket sale surge ?

It's 1,946 standard home sales. Going up in a similar way I'd expect it to the closer we get to games.

Carlisle seem to have sold their 559 now.

The Royal Forester
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 1640
Joined: 25 Dec 2015 13:53

Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

by The Royal Forester » 30 Oct 2025 15:44

Mid Sussex Royal
windermereROYAL
royals6719

Bishops Stortford 1-2!!! in the mud. Remember it well -


Yes a horrible experience, we were losing for a long time when Steve Moran volleyed a superb equaliser only for a late goal keeping mistake let them in for a late winner.


Pretty sure Maurice Evans was manager so before Steve Moran's time? may be wrong though, memory not what it was.

I do remember we lost to a last minute goal though.

The match was the First Round, 1982/83 season, so Maurice Evans would have been our manager.

User avatar
Crowbar6753
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 1048
Joined: 17 Aug 2015 23:25

Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

by Crowbar6753 » 30 Oct 2025 16:09

Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?


The Royal Forester
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 1640
Joined: 25 Dec 2015 13:53

Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

by The Royal Forester » 30 Oct 2025 16:22

Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?

According to my copy of "Biscuits and Royals", Brian Bason was here 1882-83, made 41 appearances no goals. I don't remember him, either

User avatar
Crowbar6753
Hob Nob Regular
Posts: 1048
Joined: 17 Aug 2015 23:25

Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

by Crowbar6753 » 30 Oct 2025 16:30

    The Royal Forester
    Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
    Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?

    According to my copy of "Biscuits and Royals", Brian Bason was here 1882-83, made 41 appearances no goals. I don't remember him, either


    I guess he wasn't anything special lol, however he managed to get 41 games under his belt so seems strange we cannot remember him :cry:

    User avatar
    Crowbar6753
    Hob Nob Regular
    Posts: 1048
    Joined: 17 Aug 2015 23:25

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by Crowbar6753 » 30 Oct 2025 16:36

    Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
    Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?


    This was a pretty bang average to poor Reading side from what i remember. Beavon was ok and surprised Dixon didn't bang a goal in against a non league team! I think Phil Stant was an Army player if memory serves me right and Doherty and Donnellan weren't much! Martin Hick's was a legend, all legs and like bambie on ice, a stereotypical div 4 center back :D I guess these were the dark days a few years before things slowly took off :D where was Gilksy?????

    East Grinstead Royal
    Member
    Posts: 510
    Joined: 20 May 2008 17:24

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by East Grinstead Royal » 30 Oct 2025 17:55

    The Royal Forester
    Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
    Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?

    According to my copy of "Biscuits and Royals", Brian Bason was here 1882-83, made 41 appearances no goals. I don't remember him, either


    I’m not surprised no-one remembers him, 1882 was a helluva long time ago.


    The Royal Forester
    Hob Nob Regular
    Posts: 1640
    Joined: 25 Dec 2015 13:53

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by The Royal Forester » 30 Oct 2025 18:36

    East Grinstead Royal
    The Royal Forester
    Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
    Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?

    According to my copy of "Biscuits and Royals", Brian Bason was here 1882-83, made 41 appearances no goals. I don't remember him, either


    I’m not surprised no-one remembers him, 1882 was a helluva long time ago.

    Oops. Either he was a very early player or maybe it was 1982-83

    MR. CYNICAL
    Member
    Posts: 264
    Joined: 14 Apr 2004 22:33
    Location: Basingstoke

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by MR. CYNICAL » 30 Oct 2025 18:42

    Crowbar6753
    Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
    Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?


    This was a pretty bang average to poor Reading side from what i remember. Beavon was ok and surprised Dixon didn't bang a goal in against a non league team! I think Phil Stant was an Army player if memory serves me right and Doherty and Donnellan weren't much! Martin Hick's was a legend, all legs and like bambie on ice, a stereotypical div 4 center back :D I guess these were the dark days a few years before things slowly took off :D where was Gilksy?????

    Wasn't this just before the merger attempt by Maxwell later that season?
    Donnellon was a winger signed from Watford, Doherty was playing in Local football in Reading when we signed him.

    MR. CYNICAL
    Member
    Posts: 264
    Joined: 14 Apr 2004 22:33
    Location: Basingstoke

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by MR. CYNICAL » 30 Oct 2025 18:56

    MR. CYNICAL
    Crowbar6753
    Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
    Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?


    This was a pretty bang average to poor Reading side from what i remember. Beavon was ok and surprised Dixon didn't bang a goal in against a non league team! I think Phil Stant was an Army player if memory serves me right and Doherty and Donnellan weren't much! Martin Hick's was a legend, all legs and like bambie on ice, a stereotypical div 4 center back :D I guess these were the dark days a few years before things slowly took off :D where was Gilksy?????

    Wasn't this just before the merger attempt by Maxwell later that season?
    Donnellan was a winger signed from Watford, Doherty was playing in Local football in Reading when we signed him.

    User avatar
    Crowbar6753
    Hob Nob Regular
    Posts: 1048
    Joined: 17 Aug 2015 23:25

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by Crowbar6753 » 30 Oct 2025 18:58

    MR. CYNICAL
    Crowbar6753
    Crowbar6753 Pat Earles was the scorer in the Bishop Stortford cup defeat in the mud! 2931 in attendance.
    Reading team: Fearon, Williams, White, Beavon, Hicks, Wood, Bason, Stant, Dixon, Doherty, Donnellan. I remember the game and the squad well but for some reason i cannot remember the guy called Bason? Anyone enlighten me on this guy?


    This was a pretty bang average to poor Reading side from what i remember. Beavon was ok and surprised Dixon didn't bang a goal in against a non league team! I think Phil Stant was an Army player if memory serves me right and Doherty and Donnellan weren't much! Martin Hick's was a legend, all legs and like bambie on ice, a stereotypical div 4 center back :D I guess these were the dark days a few years before things slowly took off :D where was Gilksy?????

    Wasn't this just before the merger attempt by Maxwell later that season?
    Donnellon was a winger signed from Watford, Doherty was playing in Local football in Reading when we signed him.


    Holy Cynical, now you've got my brain working!!! It has to have been as I'm not sure it was much earlier and we started picking up as a team after our 12 straight wins starting the 1985 season i believe.


    User avatar
    Pockets
    Member
    Posts: 9
    Joined: 18 Jul 2005 12:31
    Location: There when we were s**t

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by Pockets » 30 Oct 2025 20:57

    Didn't we pick Doherty up from Basingstoke?

    Sutekh
    Hob Nob Legend
    Posts: 23650
    Joined: 12 Feb 2014 14:05
    Location: Over the hills and far away

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by Sutekh » 30 Oct 2025 21:22

    The Royal Forester
    East Grinstead Royal
    The Royal Forester According to my copy of "Biscuits and Royals", Brian Bason was here 1882-83, made 41 appearances no goals. I don't remember him, either


    I’m not surprised no-one remembers him, 1882 was a helluva long time ago.

    Oops. Either he was a very early player or maybe it was 1982-83


    1982-83



    Brian Bason was a midfielder previously with Palace and Chelsea. Retired after leaving Reading and went off to run a Cornish pub I think.


    Maurice was manager while Phil Stant was bought out of the army by the club but never fulfilled his potential, instead moving on after a handful of games to score shedloads at Hereford and then Cardiff.


    Think Gary Donnellan was more famous at Reading for his return with Wealdstone in the cup in about 1985 when their tactics seemed to involve various elements of on pitch thuggery - probably unsurprising given Vinnie Jones was also playing for them.


    Mike Doherty was a striker, came from Basingstoke in 1982 and was then moved on to Slough in 1983. Managed 5 league goals in his time here.

    User avatar
    Crowbar6753
    Hob Nob Regular
    Posts: 1048
    Joined: 17 Aug 2015 23:25

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by Crowbar6753 » 30 Oct 2025 21:34

    Sutekh
    The Royal Forester
    East Grinstead Royal
    I’m not surprised no-one remembers him, 1882 was a helluva long time ago.

    Oops. Either he was a very early player or maybe it was 1982-83


    1982-83

    Brian Bason was a midfielder previously with Palace and Chelsea. Retired after leaving Reading and went off to run a Cornish pub I think.

    Maurice was manager while Phil Stant was bought out of the army by the club but never fulfilled his potential, instead moving on after a handful of games to score shedloads at Hereford and then Cardiff.

    Think Gary Donnellan was more famous at Reading for his return with Wealdstone in the cup in about 1985 when their tactics seemed to involve various elements of on pitch thuggery - probably unsurprising given Vinnie Jones was also playing for them.

    Mike Doherty was a striker, came from Basingstoke in 1982 and was then moved on to Slough in 1983. Managed 5 league goals in his time here.


    Thanks Sutekh for the info, we should do a memory lane page for each season starting in the mid 70s and working forward as there seems to be a few of us older guys around and its amazing how much you forget. Its easy to get caught up in the present however, most of my good times with Reading were on the terraces from the late 70s Elm Park days until it sadly came down.
    Best Elm Park scenes; Archie Lovell's two late goals against Wolves 2-1 and the 4-3 Plymouth comeback, good times :D

    User avatar
    stealthpapes
    Hob Nob Addict
    Posts: 9212
    Joined: 05 Jun 2013 13:25
    Location: proverbs 26:11

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by stealthpapes » 31 Oct 2025 11:12

    I think Phil Stant was an Army player if memory serves me right


    Yeah, quite the life story.

    We played him while he was based nearby. He would have served in the Falklands just beforehand. There's an ITV4 documentary where he returns to the Falklands.

    After playing for us (handful of games, two goals which I think were a brace), he doesn't play football for about 3 years before popping up in Hereford. Which, essentially, tells you what he was doing for those years.

    Scored a shedload for Hereford, Mansfield and Cardiff.

    There's a nice article about his brief time at Brighton in 2000-2001
    https://wearebrighton.com/albiondatabas ... n-history/

    User avatar
    tidus_mi2
    Hob Nob Addict
    Posts: 7909
    Joined: 15 Jun 2012 15:24

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by tidus_mi2 » 31 Oct 2025 12:19

    Do people think we have a stronger team now that when the Americans took over?

    At the time we were not getting thrashed and in a relegation fight just above the relegation zone I think?

    If this is the case we should be able to beat Reading if we play their strongest team against our strongest.

    Just browsed the match thread on the Carlisle forum and that seemed a doozy, has he forgotten they are 2 league below?

    MR. CYNICAL
    Member
    Posts: 264
    Joined: 14 Apr 2004 22:33
    Location: Basingstoke

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by MR. CYNICAL » 31 Oct 2025 12:20

    Sutekh
    The Royal Forester
    East Grinstead Royal
    I’m not surprised no-one remembers him, 1882 was a helluva long time ago.

    Oops. Either he was a very early player or maybe it was 1982-83


    1982-83



    Brian Bason was a midfielder previously with Palace and Chelsea. Retired after leaving Reading and went off to run a Cornish pub I think.


    Maurice was manager while Phil Stant was bought out of the army by the club but never fulfilled his potential, instead moving on after a handful of games to score shedloads at Hereford and then Cardiff.


    Think Gary Donnellan was more famous at Reading for his return with Wealdstone in the cup in about 1985 when their tactics seemed to involve various elements of on pitch thuggery - probably unsurprising given Vinnie Jones was also playing for them.


    Mike Doherty was a striker, came from Basingstoke in 1982 and was then moved on to Slough in 1983. Managed 5 league goals in his time here.

    Assume you got that from his wiki page which is pretty vague, his time at Basingstoke has a question Mark there.
    Do remember he was born in Liverpool but played in non league football in and around Reading, he may of been at Basingstoke when we did sign him, can't remember that bit. Do remember him more as a midfielder and don't think he signed a professional contract with us. Definitely a near the end of Wallers' time as chairman, we were struggling with some really low attendances that season.

    Sutekh
    Hob Nob Legend
    Posts: 23650
    Joined: 12 Feb 2014 14:05
    Location: Over the hills and far away

    Re: MATCHWATCH : Carlisle United (h)

    by Sutekh » 31 Oct 2025 13:41

    MR. CYNICAL
    Sutekh
    The Royal Forester Oops. Either he was a very early player or maybe it was 1982-83


    1982-83



    Brian Bason was a midfielder previously with Palace and Chelsea. Retired after leaving Reading and went off to run a Cornish pub I think.


    Maurice was manager while Phil Stant was bought out of the army by the club but never fulfilled his potential, instead moving on after a handful of games to score shedloads at Hereford and then Cardiff.


    Think Gary Donnellan was more famous at Reading for his return with Wealdstone in the cup in about 1985 when their tactics seemed to involve various elements of on pitch thuggery - probably unsurprising given Vinnie Jones was also playing for them.


    Mike Doherty was a striker, came from Basingstoke in 1982 and was then moved on to Slough in 1983. Managed 5 league goals in his time here.

    Assume you got that from his wiki page which is pretty vague, his time at Basingstoke has a question Mark there.
    Do remember he was born in Liverpool but played in non league football in and around Reading, he may of been at Basingstoke when we did sign him, can't remember that bit. Do remember him more as a midfielder and don't think he signed a professional contract with us. Definitely a near the end of Wallers' time as chairman, we were struggling with some really low attendances that season.


    No, I pulled it from Slough’s website. They say they signed Mike from Reading in 1983 where he had made a handful of appearances in the FL but was largely a mainstay of the club’s football combination team. Previously he had been at Basingstoke where he scored 19 in 61 appearances the season before joining Reading for the princely sum of £2000. Born in 1961, Mike hailed from Liverpool and had/has a brother called Tony.

    Now checking further with the former Reading players database, they say Mike scored 6 goals in 27 starts and 4 sub appearances.

    222 posts

    Who is online

    Users browsing this forum: Clyde1998, Elm Park Old Boy, Four Of Clubs, Google Adsense [Bot] and 1182 guests

    It is currently 01 Nov 2025 20:47